DNA Test Costs Toronto Couple’s Son Canadian Citizenship

Toronto Parents Unable To Get Canadian Citizenship For Their Son

A couple from Toronto has been stuck in India for five years after traveling there to find a surrogate to have their son. The father’s sperm and anonymous eggs were placed in a surrogate, who then gave birth to a set of twins – a boy and a girl.

Children who are born using surrogates in any country will be able to get Canadian citizenship if at least one of their biological parents is a Canadian citizen – the parents can then sponsor the child for citizenship or the child can apply for citizenship.

Many Canadian Citizens Go Abroad For Surrogacy

It’s not surprising that Citizenship and Immigration Canada officials would request a DNA test before bringing the children home to Canada, but what was surprising was that the boy was not genetically related to the father. It’s not exactly known what caused the mix-up: twins fathered by two people is not completely unheard of, and it is possible that a mistake was made at the fertility clinic in India.

Unfortunately, Canada’s Assisted Human Reproduction Act has made it illegal for Canadians to hire surrogates, driving some people who want to use surrogacy either underground or to other countries – like India. Situations like this Toronto couple being stranded in India were feared when paying for surrogacy become illegal in Canada.

This couple has no friends or family living in India and have no idea when they will be able to bring their boy home. So, the couple is faced with the terrible dilemma of hiding in India (they are living there illegally and could be deported if found) and waiting for Citizenship and Immigration Canada to review its policies and make changes, or leaving the boy in India.

Earlier this year, an almost identical situation was reported when a different Canadian couple went to India to hire a surrogate and eventually found that the eggs used – which were supposed to be from the Canadian mother – were from a stranger, and therefore the twins that resulted were also not eligible for Canadian citizenship.

[gravityform id=1 name=Havea Question?]
Michael Niren

About Michael Niren

Michael is a graduate of Osgoode Hall Law School in Toronto. He is a member of the Law Society of Upper Canada, the Canadian Bar Association’s Citizenship and Immigration Section and the Associate Member of the American Bar Association. Read more

The content and comments of this blog are not legal advise and and may not be accurate or complete. If you require legal advice, contact a licensed legal practitioner directly. If you post on this blog, you assume full responsibility for disclosing your identity to the public and VisaPlace nor its affiliates are not responsible for protecting your privacy nor your identity concerning your participation in our blog and you assume any risks in participating.

Customer Reviews

I could not have asked for more! The VisaPlace team are extremely professional, they know their stuff. They gave me great information, prepared my work visa application and then prepared me for the submission process. I was successful. Got my visa. 5 stars! I would give them 6 if I could.

Tim Willisin the last week

This is not an exaggeration!!! I was truly impressed with the way VisaPlace consultants handled my case. The consultants- Emily, Lauren, Takunda and Lisa, took their time to explain to me in great deal how they were going to approach my case and how they would handle setbacks, if any. Their professionalism and knowledge of the law were superb. The minor setback that came up was quickly addressed by the team. The team constantly kept me updated on the progress/status of my application; they quickly responded to my questions/concerns. They had predicated my permanent residency to be processed within 6 -12, and Indeed it was processed and completed within 6 months. Based on my personal experience, Emily and Lauren's team are the best! They deserve 5 stars!!!!!!!!!!!

George Jakan'gayoa week ago

VisaPlace helped me sponsor my husband to become a Permanent Resident of Canada. They were extremely professional. Every step along the way was explained fully and expertly taken care of. The staff responded immediately to any questions and always handled our concerns fully, taking as much time as we needed to understand where we were at in the immigration process and what to expect next. I would recommend VisaPlace with no hesitation at all. I'm sure if we had tried to navigate the immigration process ourselves, it would have been much harder.

Shirley Corriveau2 weeks ago

Associations