For a limited time, book a Visa Consultation online and save 20% off the regular booking fee! Use promo code: 2022BookmeBOOK NOW
To see our website filtered by an specific destination, select the country: You’re seing the content related to that we can help you with immigration journey. If you want to see a specific destination, immigration journey. If you want to see a different destination, click here

Supreme Court Makes It Difficult to Revoke US Citizenship

By Ella Bergquist June 30, 2017 3 min. read

Maslenjak v. United States

Out of 7,000 – 8,000 petitions a year, the Supreme Court only hears about 80 cases. This year, an immigration case made its way to the highest court in the United States. Maslenjak v. United States concerns Divna Maslenjak (a Serbian woman) on one end and the US government on the other. On Thursday, June 22, 2017, the Supreme Court ruled in favor of Maslenjak in a 9-0 vote. The facts are outlined below.

Divna Maslenjak:

The United States:

Before reaching the Supreme Court, the case started at a district court. The jury in that court could make a conviction based on whether Divna lied during the naturalization process. They indeed convicted her on the basis of this, and Divna was deported to Serbia after the jury returned a guilty verdict. As a result of this, the government took away her citizenship.

The case moved up to the United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit, and that court affirmed the prior verdict. In both courts, the US argued that a lie during the naturalization process warrants a conviction. This is the reason the Supreme Court of the United States agreed to hear the case. Their argument consists of the following:

The Supreme Court’s ruling will make it more difficult to convict somebody for lying during the process of obtaining US citizenship. This ruling adds more value to US citizenship because it prevents the government from taking away someone’s citizenship over minor infractions. This case was remanded for further consideration before a lower court.

Do you want to immigrate to the United States?

Fill out our FREE online immigration assessment, and we will get back to you within 24 hours.

WE WANT YOUR FEEDBACK!
Do you think Divna Meslanjak should be allowed to remain in the United States?

Comment below, we want to hear your opinion!

Sources:

  1. Reuters. "Justices weigh ethnic Serb woman's bid to regain U.S. citizenship." Business Insider. Business Insider, 26 Apr. 2017. Web. 30 June 2017.
  2. "Supreme Court sets higher bar for stripping citizenship." Reuters. Thomson Reuters, 22 June 2017. Web. 30 June 2017.
  3. Maslenjak v. United States. Supreme Court of the United States. 22 June 2017. Print.
Belinda Maraj Avatar

Belinda Maraj

Our experience with the team at VisaPlace has been absolutely amazing. Special thank you to Nadia Bakhtiari whom we had the pleasure of partnering with. Nadia was attentive, empathetic, knowledgeable, professional, friendly and accessible. She provided guidance and kept us in the loop every step of the way. We were so impressed with the professionalism and exceptional client experience from VisaPlace that we partnered with them for both our PR application and our citizenship application. Thank you VisaPlace and thank you Nadia!

betty klassen Avatar

betty klassen

We were switched legal teams 3 times within our time there.( This was not our doing) We weren’t impressed at all with the service almost all the way through our experience. Our review would have been 1 star. The response time was awful. To get in contact with our attorney was so difficult. And not thorough. Almost at the end, when we were almost ready to file, we got switched again, but this time, we are thankful. The attorney we got then was Andrew Diamond. He is fantastic and the reason for the 5 star rating. This is his rating. He was phenomenal. Absolutely amazing and prompt with response time and very knowledgeable, thorough and so helpful. We couldn’t have asked for better. Thank you Andrew for all you did for us!

Arash Sorkhabi Avatar

Arash Sorkhabi

I’m satisfied with the expertise and professionalism with which my case was managed and handled. I wanted to take this opportunity to thank the firm for its support. Although it has been a long process time due to Covid, Nadia has always been one of the first people to guide me step by step through the path during this stressful and unprecedented time. I strongly recommend VisaPlace to anyone seeking legal counsel.

Sarb walia Avatar

Sarb walia

I am thrilled to share that , We have just got our Permanent residence status under humanitarian and compassionate category. It was great experience to get professional service from visaplace. All team members very knowledgeable, hard worker, polite and professional. Special thanks to Yasmeen Ali, who always guide me through out processs. Its not easy task to get positive output in HM Category. I am highly recommend visaplace for any kind of immigration needs.

Shannon Wilde Avatar

Shannon Wilde

Applying for my E2 Visa was so overwhelming for me. As soon as I engaged VisaPlace all that worry and stress was gone. They guided me through the entire process and set me up for success! I would 100% recommend using them for any of your Visa Needs.

Julia Rood Avatar

Julia Rood

I reached out to VisaPlace kind of on a whim, knowing that I needed to apply for permanent residency in order to stay with my spouse and our two cats. They were immediately and incredibly responsive, and almost instantly made me feel that I was dealing with professionals who cared about my case.

I reached out to them August last year, and today got the confirmation that my permanent residency has been approved. The people I worked with in VisaPlace stuck with me through the whole process, answering any questions and assuaging any fears that I had about the process, my application, or what I needed to do. Even when my anxiety made me snappy (I apologized immediately!) they handled my case and me with professionalism and compassion. Immigration is a stressful, scary process. I wanted professionals who knew the ins-and-outs so that I had the best chance of being able to come to Canada.

And now, I get to stay in Canada with my partner of nearly 10 years, and I couldn’t be happier. I would absolutely recommend this service to anyone who wants immigration help! A big thank you, especially, to Alejandra and Nadia for handling my case. I’m so lucky to have had your help!

Sanjida Prima Avatar

Sanjida Prima

Had a great experience working with the people at VisaPlace for a Permanent Residency application! The team I dealt with (Nadia B., Krisztina T., Mansi S.) was extremely knowledgeable, prompt and handled the case with care. I would definitely recommend their services to anyone in need!