Kidney Donor Denied Visa To Canada

A woman in Toronto has end-stage kidney disease and her life would be saved by a donor, but the one person who can donate to her has been denied entry to Canada according to this article in the Toronto Star. Stethoscope

Vilma Serrano, 44, has been on the waiting list for a kidney transplant for three years, and there’s a relative in El Salvador who medical testing says is a viable donor.

He applied for a visitor visa in in October of 2011 and was denied, and applied again in January of this year but was denied again.

According to Citizenship and Immigration Canada, the man is not eligible for a visitor visa to Canada because “he was unable to satisfy the visa officer that he would leave Canada upon expiration of his visa. We understand the serious nature of this situation, but our visa officers do not make these difficult decisions lightly.”

The reasons for the denial of the visa is that the man hasn’t ever traveled outside of El Salvador, he may not leave because he has a sister living in Canada, the necessary time he would need to be here (four months) was too much time, and his does not seem to have the stable finances or employment back home that would be enough to fund his trip to and stay in Canada.

Apparently, many Toronto residents who are newcomers end up looking to family abroad for organ donations and as a result many of these visa applications are denied, according to the hospital where Vilma is staying.
A petition has been started to help get Citizenship, Immigration and Multiculturalism Minister Jason Kenney’s attention as he is the only one who could get the donor into Canada at this point.

Michael Niren

About Michael Niren

Michael is a graduate of Osgoode Hall Law School in Toronto. He is a member of the Law Society of Upper Canada, the Canadian Bar Association’s Citizenship and Immigration Section and the Associate Member of the American Bar Association. Read more

  • Nainesh Patel

    Hi, i am Nainesh Patel. i am a kidney transplant patient. i have been my kidney transplant before 13year. Now my health is good. all report are going good. so can i apply for work visa or any kind of visa for Canada.

    • Immigration Lawyers

      Hi Nainesh,
      Thank you for your inquiry, I’m glad you contacted us! I’m sorry to hear about the hardships you have faced in the past with your kidney transplant. We have helped thousands of clients enter Canada with a work permit. I do need to take a closer look at your case. Hiring an immigration lawyer will help you get answers to all of your questions plus it will also increase the chance of approval of the visa you are inquiring. Please, complete this form for me it is just a quick and easy way for me to learn more details about you and your situation so that I will be able to advise you accurately and determine the best avenue for us to take to give you the best legal advice.

      The above response is for informational purposes only and does not form a lawyer-client relationship nor should it be construed to be legal advice.

  • waseem Muhammad

    I m 31year male I have one kidney by birth I m from Pakistan.can I apply work visa of Canada.

    • Vahe Mirzoyan

      Thank you for your inquiry Waseem. I am really glad that you contacted us.

      We can absolutely help you acquire a work permit in Canada but in order to do so please Waseem, complete this form for me it is just a quick and easy way for me to learn more details about you and your situation so that I will be able to advise you accurately and determine the best avenue for us to take to get you here in Canada.


  • Mira Freiwat

    Hello Sir,

    Thank you for your question. As long as you meet the requirements of the Student Visa and provide the documents requested to support the application, then the Visa will be approved….regardless of just having one kidney. Good luck with your studies here! MF

  • Anonymous

    I am 21 years old male and i am having one kidney by birth… i am not having any type of problem ….can i apply for canada immigration student visa….

The content and comments of this blog are not legal advise and and may not be accurate or complete. If you require legal advice, contact a licensed legal practitioner directly. If you post on this blog, you assume full responsibility for disclosing your identity to the public and VisaPlace nor its affiliates are not responsible for protecting your privacy nor your identity concerning your participation in our blog and you assume any risks in participating.

Customer Reviews

Spectacular experience. Completely smooth process, they were able to answer any of my questions any time and I had peace of mind throughout the application time, which was invaluable. I have recommended them to other friends looking for assistance with their applications, and will continue to do so. Worth every penny.

Faith Cheongin the last week

Here, I would like to say thank you so very much for your kind support on extension my visit visa. I am touched and beyond words, I am grateful and thankful for your always help and cooperation. Have a wonderful day.

Setareh Rasaeiin the last week

Great law firm with great staff. My lawyer Rania did a great job for my Canadian work permit and my daughters study permit. You are great in your work. And my Para Legal officer Alicea, you are just amazing. They did not rest until my job was promptly and properly done. Always there to answer my calls, reply my emails promptly. She tried her best and the results were amazing. I recommend visa place if you need the best immigration job. Many thanks to Rania and Alicea.

Charity Musa2 months ago