Canadian Refugee Bill C-49 reintroduced as Bill C-4
Bill C-49 will be reintroduced by Public Safety minister Vic Toews and Citizenship, Immigration and Multiculturalism minister Jason Kenney under a new title, Bill C-4. Previously, the bill was rejected by all opposition parties and several human rights organizations. While aimed at the smugglers, the bill actually punishes the refugees:
Original Bill Rejected by all Opposition Being “anti-refugee”
The bill will require that anyone arriving in Canada as the result of human smuggling, such as arriving on a boat, be detained for one full year. It would also deny them the ability to apply for permanent residency in Canada for five years after their claim is approved, not allow them to apply for status based on humanitarian and compassionate grounds, not allow them temporary resident permits for more than five years as well as eliminate their right to appeal a refugee claim denial.
The No One Is Illegal Campaign has also taken shots at the label of “human smuggler”, showing a portrait of Underground Railroad champion Harriet Tubman, who help over 70 black slaves find freedom in Canada and labeling her a human smuggler.
The director of the Canadian Civil Liberties Association has also written an interesting column on the bill, which is available here.
The Bill will punish human smugglers with fines and jail time, but most human smugglers work overseas and never step foot in Canada.
Canadian Laws Already Present to Determine Refugee Threats
Canadian laws as they stand are already sufficient to determine the truthfulness of a refugee claim, identify security threats and determine the identity of a refugee claimant, which may all necessitate detention in different cases. There really is no need for the new bill, except to punish refugees further. Are you or someone you know affected by this bill? Book an appointment and our licensed immigration lawyers can help you file a refugee claim.
The content and comments of this blog are not legal advise and and may not be accurate or complete. If you require legal advice, contact a licensed legal practitioner directly. If you post on this blog, you assume full responsibility for disclosing your identity to the public and VisaPlace nor its affiliates are not responsible for protecting your privacy nor your identity concerning your participation in our blog and you assume any risks in participating.
Migrating is a hard task for anyone. Finding a job is even harder. Once I got a job offer, things started moving rapidly. So, I called used VisaPlace (Niren and associates) to assist with the process. Rania and Richard deserve the utmost respect in getting the job done. They have been patient with me and some set backs. Very professional.! Hands down, money was well spent. Thanks Rania and Richard, you make an awesome team. You'll definitely have a repeat customer with me !! I was very impressed at how well they were organized and had a positive experience. Very good and professional work led to a successful outcome. I highly recommend using VisaPlace.
I'll like to say I had an awesome initial consultation with Rania Abboud. She was knowledgeable, made the initial process easy and understood my situation. I am excited and hopeful to continue consulting this company. You do a great job for immigrants. Also, Natalie Walcz was great, she handled my situation professionally. Great team. Definitely assets to your company.
Completely smooth process. Rania did a great job in my Canada work permit. The team is absolutely competent and knowledgeable. Alicea was so amazing and was able to answer any of my questions immediately. I had peace of mind throughout the application. I would recommend them to other friends looking for assistance with their applications.